Atmospheric Responsibility and Climate Change
The global atmosphere is a vital, fragile, and precious resource. Without it there would be no life on
earth. Its overall stability is a crucial matter, not only for the sake of human welfare, but also for the sake
of all the many natural goods and services on which human welfare depends. With the build up of
greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, and as the climate continues to warm, the question of allocating
responsibility for limiting emissions has become an increasingly urgent and contentious task within the
climate negotiations. The situation is complicated by a number of factors, both scientific and political.
On the scientific side there are various types of responsibility. Greenhouse gases differ in both their
atmospheric residency times and in their capacity to cause warming. Greenhouse gases also react with
each other, with land areas, and with the oceans, sometimes re-inforcing overall warming and
sometimes reducing it. Emissions from fossil fuels can be measured relatively easily, but emissions
from changes in soil or from forests are much more fugitive, leading to disputes about appropriate
assignation of responsibility for outcomes.
Political y, the difficulty is that greenhouse gases from human activity have been accumulating in the
atmosphere for at least 150 years, and wil take at least another 100 to stabilise under the best case
scenario. For many of the governments involved in the negotiations, however, 5 year political cycles
mean that even 10 years into the future may seem like
2 shares by UN member State
Sometimes, political considerations extend the other
way around---governments may be slow to accept
responsibility for past emissions, and prefer---
especial y if it is to their advantage---to concentrate
In fact, both the United Nations Framework
Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and its
implementation framework, the Kyoto Protocol take
account of atmospheric responsibility in explicit terms.
UNFCCC notes in its preamble that: “the largestCumulative CO2 1950-2000 Shares by UN member State share of historical and current global emissions hasoriginated in developed countries” (see charts left).
UNFCCC also adopts as a principle that: “Parties should protect the climate system.on the basis of equity and in accordance with their common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities. Accordingly, the developed country Parties should take the lead in combating climate change” (UNFCCC, Art.3.1). (Source: CAIT, available at www.wri.org)
Accordingly, both treaties currently take the approach
of dividing Parties into 2 groups: UNFCCC Annex 1
(largely Northern developed countries belonging to the
OECD) and non-Annex 1 (largely developing and less and least-developed countries in the South).
While this framework goes someway towards recognising the developed countries’ responsibility in
Article 3.1, it is an approach not without difficulties, since it tends to create a bipolar “us and them”
mindset, which is not conducive to overall co-operation and co-responsibility.
Another problem is that, ultimately, greenhouse gas emissions are caused at the sub-national level by
firms, households and individuals. Since energy consumption is so closely related to economic wealth,
and since so much of the world’s energy is derived from fossil fuels, relative levels of wealth and
Current annual per capitaemissions CO2 in the richestcountries in the world (e.g. USA
Annex shares CO 2 from energy, 2000 Annex shares, GDP 2001 non-Annex I
ANAESTHESIA AND ANALGESIA: CONTRIBUTION TO SURGERY,Department of Anaesthesia, Christchurch School of Medicine, University of Otago, Christchurch, New ZealandAnaesthetists provide comprehensive perioperative medical care to patients undergoing surgical and diagnostic procedures, includingpostoperative intensive care when needed. They are involved in the management of perioperative acute pain as w
MA&UD Department – IKP-Urban (MEPMA) – Constitution of Committees at ULB Level, District Level and State Level for monitoring & evaluation of implementation of MEPMA at various levels – Modification Orders Issued. MUNCIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND URBAN DEVELOPMMENT (UBS) DEPARTMENT -06-2009. 1. G.O.Ms.No. 414 MA, dated: 4-06-2007. 2. Lr. Roc. No. 01/2008/GB, Dated: 7-04-2009 of Miss